Recurring Deposits vs. SIP: Which Investment Option is Right for You?

December 03, 2024

recurring-deposit-vs-sip-which-is-better

Investing is essential for anyone looking to secure their financial future. It provides opportunities for wealth building, inflation protection, and financial independence while promoting disciplined saving habits. But, with so many investment options available, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. When it comes to long-term investments, recurring deposits (RD) and Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) are popular choices for many. 

 

In this article, we will explore the difference between recurring deposits and SIP, helping you make an informed decision that targets your financial goals.

 

Benefits of Recurring Deposits

  • Guaranteed Returns: RDs offer fixed interest rates, ensuring a predictable return on investment. That’s because unlike mutual funds or stocks, RDs are not market-linked, meaning market volatility doesn’t have any impact on the interest rate. The only way you can earn lower interest rates on RD is by opting for premature closure. 
  • Higher Interest Rates: Recurring Deposits offer higher interest rate compared to savings account. This helps your money grow in the long term.
  • Liquidity: You can break your RD in case of emergency situations. Generally, if you break your RD within 3 months, no interest would be paid out. Also, a premature withdrawal penalty fee could be levied on the applicable interest rate pertaining to the tenure. Consider such factors before opting for RD foreclosure.
  • Safety: Being a bank product, RDs are generally considered low-risk and are insured up to a certain limit by the Deposit Insurance and Credit Guarantee Corporation (DICGC) in India.
  • Disciplined Saving: RDs encourage regular saving habits by requiring monthly deposits.

     

Benefits and Drawbacks of SIPs 

  • Market Risk: SIPs are subject to market fluctuations, meaning returns can vary significantly based on market performance. There is a risk of negative returns in the short term as well. 
  • Investment Discipline Required: While SIPs promote discipline, they require a commitment to invest regularly despite market volatility.
  • Expense Ratio: Mutual funds, especially active mutual funds, come with certain additional costs called as total expense ratio. This percentage is added to the overall value of the fund. It’s a cost that fund houses charge as operational and fund management expenses. A higher expense ratio could eat into your returns.
  • Tax Implications: Profits made via SIP investments is subject to LTCG (Long Term Capital Gains) and STCG (Short Term Capital Gains) based on the holding period. Consult a SEB-registered adviser to know the tax implications.
  • Higher Returns Potential: SIPs are generally known for providing long-term wealth growth. However, since SIP investments involve investing in market-linked products, there’s no guaranteed returns.
  • Flexibility: SIPs offer flexibility. You can start or stop investments anytime without any penalty. However, if you miss multiple SIPs, the fund house may lock your account. 

     

Recurring Deposits vs. SIP: A Quick Comparison

Now that you have understood the benefits and drawbacks of each, here's a comparative table summarising the key differences between RD vs. SIP. 

 

CriteriaRecurring Deposits Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs)
NatureFixed-income investment offered by banks.Investment in mutual funds, typically in equities or debt funds.
ReturnsFixed and guaranteed returns based on bank interest rates.Market-linked returns, which can be higher but are not guaranteed.
RiskLow-risk; capital is protected with assured returns.Subject to market risks; potential for capital loss.
FlexibilityOffers liquidity; penalty could be levied for early withdrawalHighly flexible; investors can start, stop, or modify contributions.
Investment AmountMinimum amounts typically range from ₹100 to ₹500.Can start as low as ₹100, making it accessible for many investors.
TenureFixed tenure ranging from 6 months to 10 years.No fixed tenure; can continue indefinitely based on investor preference.
LiquidityOffers liquidity High liquidity but with tax implications; can redeem units at any time (except for ELSS with a lock-in).
Ease of OperationRequires opening a Savings Account account with a bank and setting up standing instructions.Can be set up online through mutual fund platforms or banks with KYC compliance.
TaxationInterest earned is taxed as per the income tax slab of the investor.Long-term or short term capital gains tax applies only on redemption. 
SuitabilityBest for conservative investors seeking steady, low-risk returns.Suitable for investors looking for higher returns and willing to accept market risks.

 

How to Choose Between Recurring Deposits and SIP

Choosing between RD and SIP largely depends on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment horizon. Consider the following and then arrive at a decision. 

 

Choose RDs if you prefer:

  • Guaranteed returns and safety.
  • A disciplined approach to saving without the risk of market fluctuations.

 

Choose SIPs if you aim for:

  • Higher potential returns through market investments.
  • Flexibility in investment amounts and the ability to adjust contributions based on financial circumstances.
  • You are not risk averse. 

 

Ultimately, both investment options can play a role in a well-rounded financial strategy. Consider your specific needs and consult with a financial advisor if necessary.

Final Thoughts

When it comes to choosing between RD vs. SIP, it's essential to align your investment choice with your financial goals and risk tolerance. Recurring deposits offer stability and fixed returns, making them suitable for short-term goals. On the other hand, SIPs provide market-linked returns and long-term wealth creation potential. 

 

Start small, dream big! Invest in Ujjivan Small Finance Bank’s Recurring Deposit and enjoy higher interest rates! Save for your long- and short-term goals with our RD and live a stress-free financial life. Start investing with just ₹100!

 

Apply Now

FAQs

1. What is the difference between RD vs. SIP?

Recurring deposits are fixed-term investments offered by banks, while SIPs are investment options provided by mutual funds. RDs offer fixed returns, while SIPs provide market-linked returns.

2. When comparing recurring deposits vs. SIP, which is more liquid instrument?

SIPs can tend to be more liquid, as RDs may have some restrictions on immediate early withdrawal. 

3. Can I invest in both recurring deposits and SIPs as investment options?

Yes, you can diversify your investment options by opting for both recurring deposits and SIPs based on your financial goals and risk tolerance.

4. Can I increase my monthly SIP investments?

Yes, you can increase your monthly SIP investments based on your financial capability and investment goals.

5. Which investment option is better for short-term goals when I compare recurring deposits vs. SIP?

Recurring deposits are better suited for short-term goals due to their fixed returns and low risk

6. When comparing RD vs. SIP, which has a greater risk?

If you compare RD vs. SIP, the latter has greater risks as they invest in equity markets. Recurring deposits by banks are extremely safe instruments. 

7. What are some other investment options apart from recurring deposits and SIPs?

Apart from recurring deposits and SIPs, you can explore investment options like fixed deposits, stocks, bonds, real estate, and gold to diversify your investment portfolio.

8. What is the minimum investment amount for an RD or an SIP?

The minimum investment amount varies based on the bank or mutual fund scheme you choose.

9. Are there any risks involved in recurring deposits?

Recurring deposits carry minimal risk as they are backed by banks and offer guaranteed returns.

10. Can I start an SIP with a small amount?

Yes, SIPs provide the flexibility to invest even small amounts regularly, making them accessible to a wide range of investors.

Disclaimer

Latest Blogs